Your Childhood, restocked!

Vintage Favorites and new arrivals - from the cartoons you raced home for, straight to your shelf!
After School Toys Co
Shop All Shop All Retro/Vintage Nostalgia Retro/Vintage Nostalgia MOTU MOTU TMNT TMNT DC DC Marvel Marvel

Nostalgic to Newstalgic

Check the After School Special line-up

Bestsellers

Hasbro 2026 Transformers Studio Series Cliffjumper Figure
Hasbro 2026 Transformers Studio Series Cliffjumper Figure $33.99
Mattel Masters of the Universe Chronicles Movie Wave 2 Trap-Jaw Figure
Mattel Masters of the Universe Chronicles Movie Wave 2 Trap-Jaw Figure $26.99
Mattel 2026 DC Premier Core Superman Action Figure
Mattel 2026 DC Premier Core Superman Action Figure $18.99
Mattel 2026 DC Premier Green Lantern (John Stewart) Wave 2 6 1/2" Figure
Mattel 2026 DC Premier Green Lantern (John Stewart) Wave 2 6 1/2" Figure $18.99
Action figure of The Joker in packaging with DC logo
DC Premiere Wave 1 The Joker 6 1/2-Inch Core Action Figure $14.99
Action figure of Robin in packaging with DC logo
DC Premiere Wave 1 Robin 6 1/2-Inch Core Action Figure $14.99
Batman action figure in packaging with DC logo
DC Premiere Wave 1 Batman 6 1/2-Inch Core Action Figure $14.99
McFarlane 2026 DC Multiverse Vault Collection Wonder Woman Action Figure
McFarlane 2026 DC Multiverse Vault Collection Wonder Woman Action Figure $30.99

Let customers speak for us

from 5 reviews

Arrived in perfect condition! Great packing, fast shipping. A++ seller!

David
Loyal Subjects My Pet Monster 14 Inch Plush

Packed very well and shipped fast! All items arrived in perfect condition! Only thing that wouldve made it better wouldve been a couple deagile stickers on the outside. I always put fragile on all sides just to avoid any kind of situation. Still, everything arrived great! A++ 5 star 10/10 seller!

David
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles x G.I. Joe Slash x Storm Shadow Action Figure

The box was in great condition I love that they used an outer box to protect the original box as collectors we usually appreciate that quite a bit

Jerry
TMNT Classic Foot Cruiser Vehicle

Really excited for this figure. Afterschooltoys came in solid when I could not find any where else.

Kirt Thacker
DC Multiverse Wave 29 Batman Deadman Knight Terrors Action Figure

Fast delivery, great customer service. Kept me informed all the way. Will come back for more!

Kirt Thacker
DC Multiverse Wave 29 Azrael Batman Armor Detective Comics Action Figure